Recruiting guide

How to Get Recruited as a College Baseball Catcher

By Jake Discount, founder of Athlete Insite · Checked November 2026

The short answer: Know where his numbers fit, build a list of schools at that level, make a short video that shows what coaches look for in catchers, and email those coaches with his grad year, position and best number in the subject line. Then follow up every week.

What coaches look for in catchers

  • Pop time and arm: can he throw runners out?
  • Receiving: does he frame pitches and steal strikes?
  • Blocking: do balls in the dirt stay in front of him?
  • His bat: catchers who can hit play more.

The numbers by level

These are the numbers that give a senior a real shot at a roster spot and playing time, not the lowest numbers on a roster.

NumberD1D2D3 / NAIA
Pop time1.91 or faster2.02 or faster2.12 or faster
Exit velo98+ mph91+ mph86+ mph

Pop time is measured from the catch to the tag at second base. Senior-year numbers: younger players have time to grow into them. Our guidelines, not rules. Results vary.

Below these lines, junior college is usually the best place to play right away. More in What numbers do you need to play college baseball?

What to put in his video

  • Start with his best in-game footage: throwing runners out, big blocks, good at-bats.
  • Then framing clips, blocking clips and clips of him throwing runners out.
  • If his pop time is good, add a throw to the bag with a timer on screen.
  • Finish with close-up angles of his swing. Keep his name, position and pop time in the top right corner.

Keep it to 1 to 2 minutes. The full how-to: How to make a baseball recruiting video.

Email the right coaches

Email the recruiting coordinator and the coach who works with catchers, if the staff page lists one. Use a 3-part subject line: grad year, position and his best number.

Example: 2028, C, 1.98 pop

First ask if they're recruiting catchers in his grad class. If they are, ask when they start and finish. Then follow up every week with something new.

Free template

The coach email that gets replies

The fill-in-the-blank email for his position, plus the weekly follow-up.

Get the free template →

What to ask once they write back: Questions to ask college baseball coaches.

Find the schools that fit

Enter his numbers and see his projected level and schools that fit, from 1,550+ programs.

Free tool

Get your college target list in 2 minutes

Pick catcher as his position, enter his numbers and see schools at his level.

Build my list →
Jake Discount holding his college jersey

I was cut by my high school coach and had zero offers my senior year. I reached out to college coaches myself, graduated with five offers and nearly a full ride, and pitched at La Sierra University, an NAIA school. Results vary.

Next: the full plan, step by step, in How to get recruited for college baseball.

Common questions

What is a good pop time for college baseball?

For a real shot at playing time: about 2.12 or faster for D3 or NAIA, 2.02 for D2 and 1.91 for D1.

What should a catcher's recruiting video show?

Framing, blocking and throwing runners out. If his pop time is good, show a throw to the bag with a timer on screen.

Do college coaches care if a catcher can hit?

Yes. Defense gets a catcher noticed, but catchers who can hit get more playing time and more offers.